OVERVIEW: 2007 Record: 119-88-13
Standings: 2nd place - lost Cranston Fantasy Series (2nd Seed)
Joe put together a very impressive fantasy year despite never having made the playoffs before. He was the runner up in baseball and won football. The CFBL Punchers look like they will be strong again in 2008. Good core pieces, nice young complementary players and a well rounded roster makes for a dangerous team. He has a lot of flexibility too, as he has only 3 players under contract for next year and lots of decisions at reasonable prices. This is a playoff team but he might find himself hard pressed to get a bye. Some improvements are necessary for a deep playoff run.
PROJECTED LINEUP:C: Pudge Rodriguez
1B: Alex Gordon
2B: Howie Kendrick
3B: Adrian Beltre
SS: Derek Jeter
OF: Magglio Ordonez
OF: Melky Cabrera
OF:
DH:
SP: Roy Halladay
SP: Chien Ming Wang
SP: Jake Westbrook
SP: Paul Byrd
SP: Kevin Slowey
SP: Brian Bannister
SP: John Danks
RP: Bobby Jenks
RP:
BN: Gerald Laird
BN: Wilson Betemit
This team would have a payroll of ~$98 million
NEEDS:-OFers, and lots of them. Lost Torii Hunter, but OFers are easy to find
-Could use a couple bats, but more complementary pieces than studs. The core of the lineup is set
-Initially I thought he could use a strikeout pitcher, but that staff isnt bad at all. In fact, its one of the better staffs in the league. I guess everybody could use one more Ace level power strikeout starting pitcher. There are teams that need it far worse than this one, though
STRENGTHS:-Flexibility. He can take this team in a lot of different directions and play the market for value. If youre going to be weak in places, this team is weak in the easiest places to fill
-Pitching staff is underrated good. I didnt expect it but as I crunch the numbers the Punchers keep coming up just a little behind the Big Three pitching staffs(Chasers, Spics and Colts). There is a gap and this isnt an elite staff, but it is very good
-Jenks is a stud closer
-Good offensive pieces that should provide an above average offense. Studs like Mags and Derek Jeter are great cornerstones. Howie Kendrick and Alex Gordon are great young players who are going to produce. He has the hardest places to fill all sewn up with very good players
-Cheap and deep back end of the rotation. Bannister, Slowey and Danks are three guys who are slotted to start in their respective rotations. Total cost: ~1 million for the three. Dallas Braden and possibly Santiago Casilla will likely also be making starts at some point in the season. If any of them crap out he can send them down. Nice to have this much pitching help from your minors. This was what every team was hoping to do
WEAKNESSES:-Where are the Ks? The Donkey Puncher pitching staff performs like a much better staff in every area except strikeouts. Its kind of weird really. Joe has cornered the market on groundball control pitchers like Wang, Halladay and Westbrook. Dont get me wrong, he's far from the worst in Ks - those guys dont have bad K numbers at all - but there isnt an elite strikeout power pitcher on this staff. Its the only thing keeping this team from elite pitching status
-Why have Beltre at 3B when you have the best prospect in the game blocked there? I criticized this at the time and I still dont get it. Beltre is a very good player, too, and is actually cheap at $9.5 million... still, that money might have gotten him that aforementioned strikeout pitcher
-Just the slightest bit light on OBP, but well within the normal range. Im using some projections that were pretty pessimistic on Magglio and DJ's OBPs, too, so its probably not an issue.
PREDICTION:Playoffs. It wont be hard to fill in this team with the money he has left, but he still needs to do it. While this team is solid all around it doesnt impress you anywhere. No particular weaknesses, but no great strengths. Young players will have to step up for this team to really improve.
This team in a word: "Balanced." Very similar to what Mezak has done. He's making the playoffs barring lots of injuries, but could easily end up anywhere from 3rd to 6th seed. Its very neat and easy to group Pat, Joe and the Mezak Attack together. Three very balanced teams that dont wow you anywhere but also dont have any major weaknesses.
FARM SYSTEM:Top heavy in the sense that all his best players are MLB ready. Nothing going on in the low minors here. What he has is pretty damn good though. Gordon, Botts, Danks, Slowey, Bannister and Braden should all provide cheap help this year. Balentien is a great prospect. The Orioles pitchers are kind of interesting. No depth here, though. Definitely made a mistake in focusing on too many MLB ready/help now types instead of grabbing some young, high ceiling prospects. Then again, those might be the difference between the Donkey Punchers and Mezak as opposed to Sweeney and Rossi. Joe and Chris have a lot of guys who will come up and help where Pat may have to make trades to fill holes. Can Joe resist the temptation to grab more "help me now" types? HUGE Draft coming up this year. Joe is at strong risk of having a completely barren farm system by this time next year if he doesnt have a strong draft.
I want to grade this system lower but its produced so many good MLB players so far I just cant. If he didnt have Alex Gordon Id definitely drop hima good bit, but Gordon looks like he's going to be one hell of a player. Which wouldnt be a shock for the number 2 overall pick. If you look at his line this year it doesnt impress... until you see he was only 23 and skipped AAA completely. He should have some decent power, steal a good amount of bases and have a plus OBP this yearl
OFFENSE: BPITCHING: BFARM SYSTEM: B+OVERALL: BPREDICTED FINISH: 4th